To help combat the confusion between an independent contractor and an employee, the IRS established the Common Law Test. If you’re a business owner in California, you’ll use this test to classify a worker as an independent contractor or an employee.
Common-Law tests, or Right-to-Control Tests, determine whether a business can control what an employee does and how they perform. When an employer can only have control over the results of the work and not what the work is or how it’s done, it usually means the worker is an independent contractor.
The Common Law Test looks at three factors:
- Financial control: Do any parts of the business control the financial aspects of the worker’s job?
- Behavioral control: Does the company have the right to control how workers do their work?
- Type of relationship: Are there employee benefits, or is there a written contract?
Financial control
Five financial aspects impact a worker’s classification.
Profit & loss opportunity
Typically, a worker who makes more profit is an employee, while a worker with more loss is an independent contractor.
Significant investment
Independent contractors usually need to invest their money into their materials, tools and resources.
Payment method
Employees are added to the payroll based on a set salary amount. Independent contractors are paid on an hourly rate or project basis.
Unreimbursed expenses
Both employees and independent contractors can incur unreimbursed expenses. But some expenses may be reimbursed for employees.
Market services
Independent contractors can market their services and acquire more business. Employees need to follow company policy when it comes to side
gigs.
Behavioral control
Four behavioral aspects impact a worker’s classification.
Training
A business might have a set training protocol in place for employees. Independent contractors might be free from following the training protocol and can follow their own procedures.
Instruction type
It typically means the worker is an employee if there are specific requirements for how, when and where the work should be performed (resources to use, sequence, etc.).
Evaluation system
Some businesses measure employee performance, including setting targets and goals.
Instruction amount
The more instructions there are, the more control the business has over the worker. Independent contractors have more control over their work.
Type of relationship
The type of relationship between a business and a company is key to distinguishing between an independent contractor and an employee.
Benefits
Benefits, including vacation days, paid holidays, maternity leave,
health insurance and sick days are exclusively for employees.
Contracts
The contract should include how the worker and business will work together. Both can receive a contract, but the information in the contract can distinguish between the two.
Relationship
An independent contractor is typically hired for a set period of time. Employees can work at the company for an indefinite period of time.